Scientists discover new, simple way to classify marine biomes

Newly published in Global Ecology and Biogeography, research by Alli Cramer, a 2020 doctoral graduate of WSU's School of the Environment, now at the University of California Santa Cruz, and WSU Professor Stephen Katz revealed a new approach which sorts biomes based on their life-supporting potential and stability of the sea floor.

Cramer and Katz reviewed more than 130 studies to weigh variables such as light, depth, and nutrients across seven biomes incorporating dozens of environments, including coral reefs, kelp beds, ocean ice, and deep abyssal plains.

Analyzing the data inductively, rather than proceeding from an initial hypothesis, they found biomes were most clearly sorted by two strong variables: gross primary production, a measure of the energy in the food web; and substrate mobility, or the movement and composition of the ocean floor.

"This means that energy flow and mobility are common organizing forces across a wide variety of marine ecosystems," Cramer said. "Despite their differences, coral reefs and deep-sea deserts respond to the same processes."

While biomes on land have long been defined by climate, marine biomes have evaded clear categorization.

"The oceans are a big black box," Katz said. "Scientists have traditionally seen depth, temperature, and light as important. But we found that they don't capture every community. The sea's energy economy runs in other ways than just sunlight."

As a doctoral student, Cramer set about developing a more effective way to sort out marine biomes.

After analyzing many variables, "there were really only two that end up revealing the big pattern," Katz said.

Gross primary production measures the energy flowing through a marine community -- whether fueled by sunlight, the recycled 'brown food web' of the deeps, or chemicals flowing from hydrothermal vents. Coral reefs, sea ice, and mangrove swamps have high primary production, while the deep, muddy abyssal plains are marine deserts of low productivity.

The other strong variable, substrate mobility, sorted biomes on the nature of their bottom layer -- what it is made of, and how much it is moved and stirred by waves and currents. A sandy bottom that's mostly stable defines a different biome from one that's constantly in motion.

"These two axes are important forces in determining the ecosystems in the ocean, and driving their formation," Katz said.

"One of the things that's novel about this classification system is that it's simple -- so simple that nobody bothered," he added. "When we told our colleagues about this, they were surprised that no one had tried it before."

The new method could help scientists, fisheries managers, and conservationists reconsider the richness and diversity of ocean biomes as well as the value of high productivity regions being impacted by humans.

"Previous work has looked at the marine environment on an ecosystem-by-ecosystem basis," Cramer said. "By combining data from many ecosystems, we found the common thread that binds them together. This lets us see the ocean in new ways and highlights some key places where our actions may alter ecosystem function."