Can 'local acoustic treatment' reduce speech distraction within open-plan offices?

An international standard, ISO 3382-3, specifies measurements of the acoustical properties of a room and it focuses on large-scale acoustic measurements and solutions. These solutions aren't always effective for the short conversational distances in open-plan offices, according to researchers in Australia, who've discovered that open-plan spaces could benefit from additional specialized and local acoustic treatments.

During the 175th Meeting of the Acoustical Society of America, being held May 7-11, 2018, in Minneapolis, Minnesota, Manuj Yadav, a postdoctoral research associate at the University of Sydney, will present his and his colleagues' work toward solutions to the speech distraction problem in open-plan offices.

"The local acoustic treatment we've studied so far includes the use of high-back chairs -- with or without sound absorption near the head -- and 'retroreflective ceilings' that reflect sound back in the direction of the source, which allows you to hear your own voice reflected back to your ears much louder than is possible with flat or other types of hard ceiling surfaces or absorptive ceilings," Yadav said.

People tend to "simply put, lower their voices when they receive some support in the form of reflections from the room and nearby surfaces," Yadav said. "The opposite situation is true in a conversational context, in which people tend to raise their voices if they don't think their voice is audible to the person they're talking to. A somewhat extreme example is everyone progressively raising their voices within a large gathering to talk to someone at less than an arm's length, since they can't hear others or themselves -- the cocktail party effect."

Retroreflective surfaces aren't commonly used in acoustics today, so their use as a ceiling treatment in offices is a novel application. "We hope that our work encourages more researchers to explore the use of retroreflectors, which are likely to be useful in cases in which support for listening to your own voice is needed in the form of strong reflections from nearby surfaces," Yadav said.

The researchers' work with high-back chairs is also one of the first efforts to quantify the acoustic effect of chairs or furniture ensembles. "This may encourage some manufacturers of these products, which are becoming quite popular, to actually measure their acoustic effects," Yadav said. "Unfortunately, today these products are just labeled 'acoustic' for marketing purposes -- without any data or justification."

So far, Yadav and colleagues have found that their local acoustic treatment "can, in many cases, provide substantial enhancement for speech communication at short distances and reduce the disturbance due to ambient noise when you're trying to concentrate," he said. "This work, however, centers mostly on laboratory-based studies and much more needs to be done in terms of testing with actual people in different communication scenarios, but the effects are there for anyone to hear."