Many cooks don't spoil the broth: Manifold symbionts prepare the host for any eventuality

On several research expeditions Ansorge and her colleagues visited black smokers -- towering chimneys where hot, mineral-rich water gushes out of the seafloor -- and collected Bathymodiolus mussels, a distant relative of the edible blue mussel. Back in the Bremen and Vienna labs they analyzed the genomes of the bacteria inhabiting these mussels in great detail. So far it was assumed that the mussel is home to only one or two types of symbionts. However, Bathymodiolus is clearly more hospitable. "In fact, we found up to 16 different bacterial strains in a single mussel," says Ansorge.

Diversity matters

The different bacterial strains ensure that the mussel is prepared for all eventualities. They fulfill different functions, help with different metabolic conversions and have different abilities. "Different symbionts can, for example, use different substances and energy sources from the surrounding water to feed the mussel," explains Ansorge. Others are particularly resistant to viruses or parasites.

"We think that the great diversity of its tenants makes the mussel highly versatile," continues Jillian Petersen, leader of the University of Vienna lab involved in the study. If its environment changes -- which happens frequently in such dynamic habitats as hydrothermal vents -- the mussel can adapt quickly. Those bacterial strains that are particularly well adapted to the new conditions can then become more numerous. Moreover, if the mussels want to colonize new habitats, they are well prepared with this mosaic of symbionts. Obviously, the many cooks do not spoil the mussel's broth, but can actually prepare just the right broth for every occasion.

"This variety of symbionts does not fit with current evolutionary theories, according to which organisms as similar as these bacterial symbionts cannot coexist," explains Nicole Dubilier, project leader of the study and director at the Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology. This is possible due to a special feature of this symbiosis: The mussel does not feed its tenants directly, but instead ensures that they always have access to their food source at the black smokers. The symbionts obtain their food from the surrounding water. "This allows the mussel to accommodate cooks who may not be working optimally under the current conditions. You never know when they will be useful."

From Lucky Strike to Lilliput

Lucky Strike, Semenov, Wideawake, Clueless, Lilliput -- these are the names of the hydrothermal fields where Ansorge and her colleagues have so far found the hospitable deep-sea mussels. These fields are distributed along the entire Mid-Atlantic Ridge, from the Azores to far into the South Atlantic, several thousand meters under the surface of the ocean. At every location the researchers found the same pattern of unexpectedly high symbiont diversity, with minor differences in their abilities, which may be tuned to the local conditions.

"Next, we want to investigate whether this diversity also exists in other deep-sea symbioses, for example in sponges or clams," says Ansorge. "We also want to examine if our observations are typical for symbioses or if they also occur in closely related free-living bacteria, which are very common in the oceans." The researchers are expecting to find that their results are no exception, and that such a large variety of bacterial symbionts is common in other comparable systems. This would mean that we need to revise our current evolutionary theories about symbiotic relationships.