Endoscopic Therapy May Offer An Alternative To Surgery In Patients With Esophageal Cancer

Two separate studies suggest EMR is an effective treatment alternative to surgery and generally yields positive long-term results.

Dr. Ganapathy Prasad and colleagues from the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, MN reviewed the medical records of 135 esophageal cancer patients treated endoscopically (without surgery) at their clinic between 1995 and 2007. Minimally invasive techniques, such as EMR and photodynamic therapy were used to treat these patients.

After a 3.5-year follow-up, researchers found that endoscopic therapy was successful in 90 percent of esophageal cancer patients. Fourteen percent of patients had recurrent cancers, which appeared after a mean of 16 months. All of these recurrent cancers were early cancers and were treated endoscopically. Patients with recurrent cancers had longer Barrett's esophagus segments and needed more treatments to achieve remission. Overall, 83 percent of patients treated for esophageal cancer were alive at the 5-year mark.

According to lead investigator Dr. Prasad, "The results of this study show that early cancers of the esophagus can be treated endoscopically without surgery. Recurrences are uncommon and can be treated endoscopically as well, if patients are followed carefully."

CBE-EMR Effective Approach for the Management of Barrett's Esophagus

New research on an endoscopic procedure known as Complete Barrett's Esophagus Endoscopic Mucosal Resection (CBE-EMR) reveals this approach may hold promise as a minimally invasive technique offering an effective treatment alternative to surgical removal of the esophagus for Barrett's esophagus.

In a retrospective study of a prospectively collected database conducted at the University of Chicago, Dr. Jennifer Chennat and her colleagues, under the direction of Dr. Irving Waxman, examined medical records of 48 patients who underwent CBE-EMR for the treatment of Barrett's esophagus with high-grade dysplasia or intramucosal carcinoma from August 2003 to May 2008.

Patients received careful endoscopic examination using high definition endoscopy with narrow band imaging. Endoscopic ultrasound was used prior to CBE-EMR to detect any invasive esophageal cancer or abnormal lymph nodes.

Patients continued to take proton pump inhibitors twice daily to decrease gastric acid production and reflux into the esophagus. After the CBE-EMR was completed, patients underwent an endoscopy every six months with biopsies taken every 1 cm throughout the entire length of the prior resected BE area, and also from 1 cm above the prior resection margin.

"Mucosal biopsies provide smaller pieces of tissue, while endoscopic mucosal resection provides more comprehensive tissue analysis. You're seeing not just the trees, but also the entire forest," explained Dr. Chennat.