Unconventional treatment strategy controls -- rather than eradicates -- cancer

Despite aggressive treatment, complete cancer eradication is rare and toxic side effects all too common. Recently, researchers have questioned the benefits of standard chemotherapy because while it destroys drug-sensitive tumor cells, it leaves behind drug-resistant cells. By eliminating the former population of tumor cells, the drug allows resistant cells to take over and drive tumor growth uncontrolled.

Taking into account the evolutionary forces that drive cancer resistance, Pedro Enriquez-Navas and colleagues designed an evolution-based treatment strategy that adjusts the drug dose based on how the tumor responds. Rather than trying to shrink the tumor completely, the so-called adaptive therapy seeks to stabilize the tumor by maintaining a small population of drug-sensitive tumor cells to suppress the growth of resistant cells.

The researchers tested the approach with the chemotherapy drug paclitaxel in mice with two different types of breast cancer. Standard chemotherapy shrunk the mouse breast tumors, but only to have them grow back as soon as treatment stopped. Another treatment regimen that skips doses whenever the tumor shrunk also inevitably resulted in tumor progression.

In contrast, adaptive therapy consisting of high initial drug doses followed by progressively lower doses as the tumor responded was more effective in controlling tumor growth than either standard therapy or dose skipping.

In fact, the treatment allowed between 60 and 80% of the mice to be weaned off the drug completely without relapsing for an extended period of time. A related Focus by Giannoula Klement discusses how the study's eco-evolutionary model of cancer may prompt researchers and clinicians to rethink current therapeutic strategies for cancer.