Invasive lionfish may be a selective predator

On the fringing reefs of Curacao, hungry lionfish were placed within artificial enclosures designed to simulate natural conditions. Three prey fish species were selected for the trials -- brown chromis, bluehead wrasse and masked/glass goby -- based on their relative abundance in the reefs and their prevalence in the lionfish diet in Curacao.

Although the ecological consequences of invasive lionfish are often attributed to their unique predatory strategies and broad diet, the experiments revealed that most lionfish actively selected their prey species, exhibiting a strong preference for the brown chromis over the other two. This study first appeared online January 2020 and was subsequently published in the March 2020 bi-monthly issue of Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology. These findings suggest that their foraging behavior is not strictly proportional to prey availability given the abundance of other equally or even more vulnerable species in the enclosure. Alternatively, the scientists noted that lionfish in poorer condition were less selective, often going for the most accessible prey.

"Our study shows active discrimination by lionfish among the top three prey species on Curacao reefs, and an influence of how well-fed an individual was before hunting its prey, on the strength of its preference," said Michele Pierotti, STRI fellow and senior author of the study. "In other words, as long as they are not starving, lionfish can be very picky about their daily menu."

This represents the first experimental, field-based study to provide direct evidence for active prey choice in this invasive predator. Given the considerable variation in lionfish diet across the invaded range, and the unlikelihood of controlling its continued expansion, further understanding of lionfish diet choices could provide additional insight into their impact on reefs and improve predictions of how they might affect newly invaded communities.

"More researchers might consider using this experimental method -- of transforming the field into a working laboratory -- to obtain a more accurate representation of what is happening on coral reefs," said Amelia Ritger, who led the experiment in the field and is now a doctoral student at the University of California, Santa Barbara. "Setting up and maintaining the field enclosures is a lot of work, requiring multiple dives every day, but it certainly pays off."