A single genetic switch changes butterfly wing color

To conduct the study, which was published Oct. 25 in Current Biology, the researchers developed a genetic map using white and yellow H. cydno butterflies. They then studied genome sequences to identify a single gene called aristaless1 (al1) that acted as a switch for yellow and white coloration.

Most Heliconius species closely related to H. cydno have yellow spots on their wings; H. cydno has subspecies that are either yellow or white. The researchers saw that the butterflies with white spots have elevated expression of al1 (i.e. it's switched "on"), meaning that it may play a role in repressing yellow pigmentation from being produced. Using CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing tools, the scientists confirmed this function of al1. When they knocked it out (or switched it off) in embryos of butterflies that should be white, those butterflies developed yellow spots instead.

"For decades people have been cross-breeding these butterflies and they knew that this white vs. yellow switch was in one spot in the genome. They just weren't able to trace it to the actions of a single gene," said Marcus Kronforst, PhD, associate professor of ecology and evolution and senior author of the study.

"Now with CRISPR we can knock the gene out and see what happens. It turns out the evolutionary innovation here is not one species gaining a pigment, but instead turning on a gene to repress an ancestrally present pigment," he said.

Kronforst and his team also traced the evolutionary history this color patterning by comparing genetic differences in the H. cydno version of al1 to those of other, closely-related Heliconius species. The white version of the gene appears to be a relatively new development. While H. cydno was the first species to develop white forms, there are signs of cross-breeding that introduced the white color into other species at a later time.

There is also evidence that the same gene may be linked to mating preferences for color. White H. cydno males prefer females with white spots; yellow males likewise prefer yellow females. Scientists have long known that genes for both color patterning and mate preference in H. cydno are located in the same area of the genome.

"Now that we know the molecular basis of the color, we can start asking how preference is linked to it," Kronforst said. "Are they two genes near one another or is it somehow the same gene doing both jobs?"

While Kronforst and his team don't yet know if mate preference is controlled by al1 or another gene nearby, the close proximity could account for the diversity of Heliconius species.

"Whether it was natural selection driving it or it was just chance that these two things are linked, that might be part of the reason why we have such a diverse group of butterflies," he said. "When the color and preference for the color are linked together, it causes these things to evolve together very rapidly."

The study, "Aristaless controls butterfly wing color variation used in mimicry and mate choice," was supported by the Chicago Biomedical Consortium, Big Ideas Generator funding from the University of Chicago, the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, the National Institutes of Health, Harvard's FAS Center for Systems Biology, the Pew Biomedical Scholars program, the University of Chicago Neubauer funds, and the National Science Foundation. Additional authors include Erica Westerman from UChicago and the University of Arkansas; Nicholas VanKuren, Darli Massardo, Ayse Tenger-Trolander, Erick Bayala, Kenneth Barr, Nathan Buerkle and Stephanie Palmer from UChicago; Wei Zhang from UChicago and Peking University, China; Ryan Hill from the University of the Pacific; Nicola Chamberlain from Harvard University; and Tracy Douglas from Rice University.