How A Little Bit Of Cold Can Kill A Big Manatee, And What It Might Mean For The Species

The work, described in the current edition of the journal Aquatic Mammals, could significantly improve treatment for cold-stressed manatees. It could also help decide an ongoing controversial debate regarding the manatee's state endangered species status and aid in the development of plans to minimize the effects of power plant shutdowns on the manatees who have grown to depend on the warm water they release.

During cold spells, sick, sometimes emaciated manatees at times wash up along the coast of Florida afflicted with a puzzling combination of skin sores and infections that clinicians historically treated as separate ailments. In the new paper, lead author Dr. Gregory Bossart, Director of the Division of Marine Mammal Research and Conservation at HARBOR BRANCH, and colleagues, explain how long-term exposure to cold water can be responsible for this multi-faceted condition.

The team found that the cold stress syndrome stems from a cascade of physiological events and diseases initiated by cold water and manatees' limited ability to adapt to low temperature extremes. The study suggests that the animal's metabolism slows, leading to digestion problems, decreased appetite, and associated weight loss. These events, along with the possible release of certain hormones, weaken manatees' immune systems, making them vulnerable to environmental toxins as well as a variety of diseases, including pneumonia, intestinal infections, and perhaps even a manatee virus similar to one that causes human cervical cancer. This progression and its results are surprising given that manatees are known for their outstanding immune systems.

"This syndrome opens up the manatees to the long-term pathologic effects that can predispose the population to many other problems," says Dr. Bossart, who has studied both clinical marine mammal medicine and pathology and human pathology.

In the study, investigators performed necropsies--the animal form of an autopsy--on 12 manatees thought to have died from cold stress syndrome during the exceptionally harsh winter months between November 2000 and April 2001. Researchers found that each manatee showed signs of starvation, including a thinned blubber layer and an overall sunken appearance. In addition, at least 75 percent of the animals had an abnormally low number of disease-fighting white blood cells called lymphocytes, various skin and intestinal lesions, heart degeneration and pneumonia.

Knowledge that the cold can cause even more devastating and extensive effects than previously realized could help managers decide how to deal with the closing and deregulation of aging and under-used power plants. More than 500 manatees have been spotted basking in the heated water near a single power plant on one winter day, according to Winifred Perkins, manager of environmental relations at the Florida Power and Light Company. Historically, manatees migrated only to relatively warm freshwater springs or far enough south to avoid colder water, but now reports indicate that over 60% of the population has grown accustomed to instead spending winters near balmy discharges from industrial plants. As outdated power plants are shut down these electric blankets are removed and some manatees are not able to find substitutes in time.

Manatees already die each year from the cold, and the fear is that future power plant closings and replacement with more efficient facilities that don't churn out heated water could increase the number of deaths. "Some of these power plants provide warm water for up to hundreds of manatees and when you shut one down you could be talking about losing a substantial portion of the remaining population," says Dr. Bossart. In the past, manatee deaths are thought to have been caused by shutdowns of a power plant in Jacksonville and a paper mill in Fernandina Beach.

Florida officials are considering various means to address the problems surrounding manatee dependence on industrial outfalls. Potential solutions range from strict management of power plant closings to the creation of a network of artificial warm water refuges to replace decommissioned facilities. In the meantime, this new understanding of cold stress should improve efforts to treat and rehabilitate rescued manatees with the syndrome. Instead of dealing with each symptom in the sick manatees, and potentially releasing animals in need of further care, Dr. Bossart says now rehabilitators can deal with the overall syndrome, which is physically far-reaching and can last for months.

The study comes at a critical time when the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission is discussing whether to down-list the Florida manatee classification with the state government from endangered to threatened. Although the downgrade would not impact current manatee protections such as slow speed boating zones and manatee sanctuaries, some environmentalists fear the change could give the public the impression that the manatee population is safely stabilized, eventually leading to loosened protection measures. Proponents of down-listing point to an increase in the population from about 1,500 in 1991 to the current rough estimate of 3,000.

However, the inevitable shutdown of power plants should be taken into account in the debate over the manatee's endangered status, according to the study authors, because the closings could dramatically increase mortality in a population that already suffers from various threats such as boat collisions and red tide poisoning. Furthermore, Dr. Bossart says the cold stress syndrome could cause future reproductive and health problems for those manatees that survive the initial cold exposure but are not brought into rehabilitation facilities. The state wildlife commission is expected to decide on the status issue this November.